Smooth34 Posted March 1, 2012 Share Posted March 1, 2012 It is interesting that IMO we will need virtually all of the top teams to choose to participate in the event for it to be viewed as a championship. If all of the top teams are there, then I do not see why it matters if it is an IHSAA or IHSWCA event. While I appreciate the hard work that went into the formula, I don't think it can be viewed as a true championship since not every team has an opportunity. At some point, one of the best teams in the state will not be invited to this event. I know how people will respond "it's impossible to do right now" and "we can grow this event in the future". For example, what if Penn is one of the best 3-4 teams in the state next year (any class). They've already been locked out of the event. Bellmont is losing a lot of studs this year, but I would never bet money against that team reloading. Yet, according to the "Official Qualifying Scores" they aren't being considered for the 3rd wildcard in 2A. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ENoblewrestling Posted March 1, 2012 Share Posted March 1, 2012 While I appreciate the hard work that went into the formula, I don't think it can be viewed as a true championship since not every team has an opportunity. At some point, one of the best teams in the state will not be invited to this event. I know how people will respond "it's impossible to do right now" and "we can grow this event in the future". For example, what if Penn is one of the best 3-4 teams in the state next year (any class). They've already been locked out of the event. Bellmont is losing a lot of studs this year, but I would never bet money against that team reloading. Yet, according to the "Official Qualifying Scores" they aren't being considered for the 3rd wildcard in 2A. One wildcard spot will be awarded next season to avoid situations like this. Id be willing to bet that under this situation you would be getting at least the top 2-3 every year (probably more like 4-5) down to the state finals. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Smooth34 Posted March 1, 2012 Share Posted March 1, 2012 One wildcard spot will be awarded next season to avoid situations like this. Id be willing to bet that under this situation you would be getting at least the top 2-3 every year (probably more like 4-5) down to the state finals. My mistake, I forgot about the 4th wildcard. Still, I think it's going to happen at some point -- where a top team is not invited to the IHSWCA Super Duals. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Y2CJ41 Posted March 1, 2012 Share Posted March 1, 2012 What if there are two teams deserving of the wild card? Someone will be left at home. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
NickS Posted March 1, 2012 Share Posted March 1, 2012 While I appreciate the hard work that went into the formula, I don't think it can be viewed as a true championship since not every team has an opportunity. At some point, one of the best teams in the state will not be invited to this event. I know how people will respond "it's impossible to do right now" and "we can grow this event in the future". On the contrary, every team does have an opportunity to be invited and compete in this event. Check out the official team scores again: http://indianamat.com/messageboard/index.php/topic,21576.0.html You'll see the teams in these standings are the same teams that are listed in each and every IHSAA sectional. Every team had an opportunity to prove what they were capable of throughout the individual state tournament. The only differences between what the IHSWCA is doing, and what the IHSAA had, are qualifying criteria and scoring systems. To advance to the team portion of the IHSAA tournament, a team had to score the most points in their particular sectional. To advance to the IHSWCA tournament, a team had to score the most points in their particular semi-state or win one of the wildcard spots. (The only part that can be considered remotely arbitrary is the coaches' vote for the 3rd and 4th wildcards. But to even qualify for a coaches' vote, a team has to be within 30-35 points. In other words, they still have to perform well.) For example, what if Penn is one of the best 3-4 teams in the state next year (any class). They've already been locked out of the event. At this time, Penn is in position for the 4th wildcard. Along with Franklin, Lake Central, and Center Grove. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts