Y2, I'm at a cross roads. For a while I've read your posts about classing state and how Garrett and other small schools are at a disadvantage because they just don't have the numbers to compete with larger schools.
I have never liked this argument. Being a young minded person, I may be a bit naive due to a lack of experience I have, but I say build your program. Since I was young the thing I desired most was to take a team and build it to the likes of Mishawaka. I talked to a group of coaches awhile ago about what they felt was important in building a strong program. One of the top things they stated was a strong feeder program. I have thought this through over the last year and understand the amount of work and time that is required.
Starting with the elementary students, if you got three kids in 4th, 5th, and 6th grade (9 total) to join a club wrestling team by the time they reach middle school they will have a solid foundation. I also understand by the time the years get to middle school half or more will drop off, however I believe if you play your cards right, the number of kids in the elementary program will grow as well.
Creating a foundation and getting kids interested at a young age will help build a program. I look at Jimtown High School, they have a very respectable program and Coach Kern does a heck of a job getting kids involved. These kids start young and by the time they are in middle school they are solid wrestlers ready to make a jump from middle school to high school. A side note, look for Jimtown to have a very good team for some time to come.
It has been because of this mindset I have disagreed with you on classing the individual tournament. However, since the topic of keeping team state in place came up I've thought more about the growth of wrestling. I believe classing the team portion would give Indiana growth in wrestling and would still allow us to have a tough individual series as well. I also began to think about classing the individual side of wrestling in Indiana.
Three of the top teams in the US in wrestling have classed individual tournaments. Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Iowa are all classed and it would be hard to find someone to argue against their dominance compared to other states in the sport of wrestling. Many of the top teams in each class still face off during the season and many of the top wrestlers still face off on the weekends during tournaments. These states make it work and turn out wrestlers every year that get recruited by D1 colleges.
Today I will say I would welcome class wrestling. I believe it would get more kids out for multiple reasons, Y2 has touched on a couple already. The one I think would be the biggest attractor is wrestlers would have more success in the state tournament. Yes, some weights in particular classes would be somewhat watered down, but with time more wrestlers would build more competition in each class. With success come more guys wanting to be apart of success, lets face it success is contagious. You would have three times the opportunities to place at state.
Y2, congrats, I'm a believer.
My only disagreement, and I'm not sure its a disagreement is that I would like to see team state stay in place. I feel many wrestlers join the team to be apart of the camaraderie that a team provides. I think without the team aspect, some school's practices would become a club of sorts where wrestlers only care about themselves and the wrestlers with the lesser skill set would get left out or behind. This would create a survival of the fittest environment. With the team, each member is worried about helping the team by building the weaker wrestlers up and helping where they can.