The Yorktown Community Schools school board policy on transfers is here: http://www.yorktown.k12.in.us/download.axd?file=0bb2f3f3-3aff-4c8e-9235-ed42fa3a7d94&dnldType=Resource
The pertinent sections are (in my opinion):
(From Page 2):
The decision on acceptance of a non-resident student will be based upon:
? The student?s attendance record at the previous school;
? The student?s academic record at the previous school. For a transfer to third grade or above, and if the previous school recorded grades, the student must have at least a C+ (2.75 on a 4.0 scale) during the prior two years of school enrollment; those transfer students enrolled prior to or during the 2010-2011 school year or any prior school year, must maintain at least a C (2.0 on a 4.0 scale);
? The student?s discipline record at the previous school;
? Class sizes in the grade level in which the student wishes to enroll at Yorktown Community Schools; and
? Whether the transfer will place an undue burden on the Yorktown Community Schools. The transfer shall not place an undue burden on the Yorktown Community Schools.
(From Page 4):
8. Reciprocal agreement between the Superintendents of both a sending and / or receiving corporation is required for any final approval.
- and -
C. The student may not have missed any more than five (5) days of school the previous semester from his/her sending school. The receiving school may consider exceptions for more than five absences due to medical conditions that can be documented by a physician but is not obligated to do so.
D. The student may not have been tardy any more then five (5) times to school the previous semester from his/her sending school.
Now, personally I disagree with the entire line about the determination of whether or not a student is requesting a transfer solely for athletic purposes. I view this as a purely subjective matter. However, it is a criteria that has been added to the policy, and as such should be enforced I suppose.
Again, these citations are from Yorktown's transfer policy:
(From Page 2):
Requests by parents, guardians, or custodians of Indiana students who do not reside in the Yorktown Community Schools district but who wish to enroll their child in the school system will be considered for enrollment if:
? Non-resident enrollment is for educational reasons;
(From Page 4):
G. Under no circumstances will a transfer student be accepted for athletic reasons.
Without any concrete evidence, all of the talk about coaches recruiting is hearsay. If it is true, then it is a shame that kids within the system who "play by the rules" may have to take a backseat to transfer athletes so that the team may be more successful.
I believe that the criteria layed out is faulty -- the subjective clauses don't belong in there. If the student in question (or any student whether or not they are an athlete) meet the objective criteria, then they should be considered for transfer and allowed to participate in sports. There should be a system in place (verifiable) where any school system can show that if they do not accept all transfers, then there is a systematic method for choosing which students are allowed to transfer and it uses academic criteria as the primary determinant.
Because the subjective criteria is included, it leaves the door open to interschool bickering.
It is a real shame that whatever the reason, and which school is "right" and which is "wrong", there is a young man who is not able to participate in wrestling this year. 4 years is a short time -- most of us remember how quickly it can pass by. I hope that he does receive a first class education at Yorktown and is able to parlay that into future success.