Math was right (at least I think). I said it was not an exact science though. If I missed something else on that one or another let me know I'll try again.
Grimes Total 16
Wedding Total 19
Duckworth Total 23
Atwood Total 25
Mappe Total 31
How the bracket pans out then was probably where you thought it was wrong
Grimes 1st
Duckworth 2nd (Wedding same side as Grimes so can't be second)
Wedding 3rd
Mappe 4th (Atwood in same quarter final round as Duckworth so he would be out of top 4)
I came up with a total number of 21 for atwood.....maybe i did something wrong
Forget math, I'm going with my gut-instinct.
1.Atwood
2.Wedding
3.Grimes
4.Mappes