Vision Quest is always a classic, but aside from an underdog striving to beat the stud it didn't have a lot. The rest of the story wasn't that great which is probably why it doesn't get much attention from the none wrestling world.
Reversal took on some darker wrestling issues, which may or may not have been that great for highlight what the sport really was. It did have some decent parts, but over all the rest of the story just doesn't do much for the none wrestling view.
One More Shot I never got around to watching, but the word I have got is that it was another underdeveloped wrestling movie.
If people don't get the studio backing and quality writers on the movie I don't think any wrestling related movie will end up being as good as it could have been. You don't have to have the biggest star names to get a wrestling movie to get the mainstream publics attention. However, you will need to hav ea film crew, a director willing to understand wrestling, and a well written human drama story with wrestling being the avenue that story is delivered through.
I guess if someone wanted a little more mainstream viewer to also take interest they would have to find some quality writers that can tell a great human struggle story and package it around that human being connected with wrestling. Just telling a wrestling story in general wont do much for the mainstream viewer . On the same wavelenght just telling a human stuggle with just bits of wrestling isn't enough either since you could plug any sport into that an make it feel the same (ie most sports movie they try to make). A person would have to find the perfect mix of the human drama story and weave the aspects of wrestling that make it unique to all other sports.
This could also be done in a documentary style film instead if thats someone goal. It just takes finding the right kid or program and knowing how to edit all the hours of footage into a great human stuggle story.
I thought of a decent wrestling film while in school, but then the movie The Rookie (Dennis Quad) took the basic idea of it. A former stud wrestlers on track to be an Olympic hopeful gets hurt in college and ends his career. He finishes out school and turns into a teacher and coach for a rough local high school with a struggleing program. He is able to mentor his team that had no direction and focus. They stay out of trouble and on the right track on their way to several notworthy wins. He ends up getting back into wrestling shape in his mid-30's after practicing with his state bound high school stud which no one else in the room can even hang with. Somehow he gets talked back into competing in a regional competition and starts lightly training with some former teammates and friends. He wins the competition which is a qualifier for the Olympic trials. He then kicks up the training more as the school, town, and former college team gets behind him. The the underdog climbs his way through the competition edging out wins over the competition. He re-injurys himself on one match but guts out the match and wins. With a laging injury he eventually faces either an old college rival whose already won an Olympic medal or some famous young stud who suppose to be the choosen one for the Olympics. He may or may not win the match in the end. If he lost he would leave the shoes in the middle of the match and get a huge ovation from the crowd who knows the entire story.
Sounded like a good idea until The Rookie "stole my thunder.
Y2, We can always throw Nick in as the famous young stud he faces at the end of the movie.