AJ,
The answer is NO.
There are no 4-time or 3-time runner-ups that have not won the state.
There are more than a few 2-timers.
But just for discussion purposes consider the following:
The three thirds and never a title:
Mike Runyon- Bloomington South- 3rd at 119, 130, and 135 in 87, 89, and 90.
The four fourths and never a title:
Nick Koons- Bellmont- 4th at 112, 119, and 130 in 98, 99, and 01.
Jay Mack- Merrillville- 4th at 98, 112, and 126 in 83, 84,and 85.
Robert Patty- Bloomington- 4th at heavyweight in 37, 38, and 39.
Sidney Hill- Terre Haute Wiley- 4th at 100 (twice) and 115 in 32, 33, and 34
TheAncientElder (TAE)
The Imperial Potentate and Grand Poobah of Classless wrestling in Indiana.
I wear my Fez with pride.
www.theancientelder.net