So let me get this straight. Everyone who's opinion is that Micic can AA his true freshman year is invalid unless they wrestled in college? What's funny is that you're assuming that I know nothing about college practice rooms just because I didn't wrestle in college. Do I know the daily grind of D1 college practice environment, no but I'm sure neither do 99% of wrestling forum posters. What if I took my son to a couple top 5 D1 college room to workout and he beat the type of wrestlers previously mentioned? He's also rolled around with NCAA round of 12/16 and AAs at the same practices and needless to say, didn't fare as well. In fact, we're even blessed to have additional wrestlers along with current AAs who come home to visit and practice at least several times during the season because they want to stay in shape. What i'm learning during these practice sessions is that I know that my son has benefited from the latter competition in order to reach whatever goal he sets for himself.
No one is questioning the toughness of the competitors in the practice room, it's about rather or not those wrestlers can help top ranked wrestlers achieve AA status. I personally know a current NW wrestler and he's a hard worker and very competitive but at the end of the day, he's not a D1 AA caliber wrestler. This young man has been in the room for 3 years now and when he comes back home to visit, always gives back to the club that he's been involved with for years. I don't care if a wrestlers goes 0-100 during his collegiate career, sticking it out for 4 or 5 years shows toughness in itself.
As far as Tsirtis being in the room, sure that helps Bryce Brill because they'll be close to the same size but Micic will be greatly undersized. Since I didn't wrestle, I guess that's an invalid point as well. Tsirtis will be able to offer him valuable advice and etc but he'll be to big to go all out when it comes to live sessions against a 125#/133# wrestler.
All i'm saying is simply this, competing against ncaa qualifiers and AAs will get you farther in any sport than the opposite of the spectrum. I can separate the difference between toughness and accomplishments and not make it personal.