It's fine that others would do it differently from the poll you took, but you keep avoiding whether by the rule provided, the referee was in the wrong. I'm not asking your opinion, I'm asking that after reading the rule and interpreting, can we agree that the referee in question was well within his right to make the decision he did. All I'm saying is that the referee didn't deserve the criticism when he made the right call. You may not have agreed or liked it, but he was well within his right. I understand that not everything is black and white, and the grey world we live in provides referees some latitude, but in your son's case, the referee made the correct call, give the guy at least that much, if anyone is wrong it's you for blasting the guy for making the right call. I promise you, this is my last response to the post, as someone who is regularly questioned by decisions I make with people's children, I feel for the referees out there, especially when they are right!