If the kid was good enough to qualify for state before, but pull a stupid thing like that, then yes. That is a disgrace to a program and a school. If you are mad, keep it under control and try to get your points, but go out trying, that is a real wrestler. You do not give up like that, and if he didn't care anymore, then he could just fall to his back, but NEVER walk off of the mat during a match!!! For a stupid thing like that, he SHOULD be punished, and the best way to prove the point is not allowing him to wrestle at state. Like it or not, that's exactly what I would do if I was his coach.