The questions was about a FF and a Bye. Not wrestler A and a Bye. C-Pink Please don't attack me on the rules if you are going to change the senerio presented from when I made my statement. I said that the FF moves on but does not directly recieve advancement points by moving on. Since the FF would then not win his next match he would not move on getting any more advancement points, bonus points, or anything else. FF can not recieve any team points, and that is following the rule book. Besides you do not automatically recieve advancement point for a wrestlers getting a bye until the next match is concluded. So based on your changed senerio I am still correct in saying you would move passed the bye and no advancements points would be rewarded. If you gain them later by winning your next match that is later not right when you recieve the bye because it is unclear what would happen in the next match at that point.
As for the weight loss issue I guess you should check with someone else on that one since you believe I am apparently incorrect on the iterpretation of it. All I know is their have been a few cases in the past year where people have been called out on the rule and school penalized as a result of not following it correctly. While their have been very few of these issue it has happened before. I just go by the information on the issue that has been presented over the last several years by different coaches. While their is much confusion on the issue I know by at least following my guidelines we are within the letter of the rule for why the weight plan was established in the first place. That is to ensure healthy weight loss for the wrestlers. Because of that our method would have not problem correctly complying with the managment plan. If as you said this dramatic weight cutting "happens all the time" where a wrestler does lose more that 1.5% and wrestle a lower wieght class that doesn't necessarily mean everything is correct. Their is a chance they could have followed the rule incorrectly, but since its the coaches job to check it and no one elses it got overlooked. It is up to each coach to correctly follow the rules set in place, and they are in chage of following the weight managment plan. So reguardless of the weight loss issue and who is right and wrong on our parts for the wrestlers sake I hope the coaches are following the rule correctly. Maybe I am wrong on the exact interpretation of how the 1.5% works but at least by using my interpretation of the rules I know we have still legally followed the weight loss plan with each of our wrestlers anyway.