When talking to a former coach from a Catholic school from up north, he was explaining to me how the school he coached at was able to recruit and why a school like MD is not. Where he coached, his school was not part of the Diocese and did not have a formal feeder system, in fact, according to him, his Parochial school was formed more like a corporation and was run more like a private academy. His explanation to me was that because of their set-up, they weren't bound to the same rules and regulations that govern other Catholic schools such as MD and Memorial, schools who do have a distinct system of schools that feed directly into them. I'm still not exactly sure how this all works out, but when he was explaining it to me, the distinction did make some sense, however, I was still unclear on if those schools without feeder systems were allowed to openly recruit, or if they had boundaries in which they had to operate within.
But honestly, with all of the new programs: voucher, school choice, and recently there was a meeting at Central H.S. (I didn't attend - so if anyone did and knows what came out of it, let me know) about home-schooled students and those attending a charter school (like Signature School here in Evansville) being allowed to participate in athletics at the public schools, I think you're going to see a lot of changes. In fact, I think it's fair to say, that you could eventually be seeing Public schools becoming "magnets" for certain sports/activities, (i.e. Reitz = Football School, Harrison = Baseball School)...these are JUST EXAMPLES...but if you had a kid who was an awesome football player, and with the school choice program you were able to send him to a football powerhouse (for free - no additional cost or tuition), why wouldn't you? I don't think there is one of us out there that wouldn't want to do the best we could for our child whether it be for football, baseball, band, academics, etc.
As the ghosts of baseball past whispered to Kevin Costner..."If you build it, they will come....."