I heard many of the same sort of comments at the Regionals. Just because certain fans didn't hear them doesn't make it not so. I also agree that alignment is alignment and you just have to wrestle.
As for the economic factors, like it or not, they are a real concern for the schools and the parents. May not seem like much, but if you're living closer to the economic edge, as many people are or soon will be, then it does effect things.
You want it summarized, Perception Equals Reality. The general perception was someone cried and got what they wanted and now everyone has to rearrange just for that reason. I think we all know that is realistically not a factor as realignments happen from time to time, but I have to agree that the geographic split makes no sense at all. Does it balance the talent pool? For a year it might, but over the next year or two it will skew again and I will bet you anything certain schools will fight tooth and nail to not go to the Central Sectional again.