Trying to get some opinions on how the Elementary duals were started in Indiana. I've been a part of wrestling here in the state with my older boys and now im at the last stage of the elementary scene with my youngest son. Its been a great learning experience for me and I've met probably the best group of coaches that a sport could have. Even in times of stress of bickering across the mat, somehow by the end of the day we meet, shake hands and laugh about how emotional we get with the sport and our wrestlers. My question is this....and feel free to correct me if my interpretation is incorrect.
The ISWA Elementary duals began to give our younger wrestlers the high school dual atmosphere which in my opinion, it has accomplished. I couldn't begin to name the number of matches where both sides of the mat were on the edge due to the intense nature of some of the wrestlers. I think its a great learning experience and it DOES build team unity at an early age. If you can get a good number each year to buy into this, after a couple of years, you will have a nice start to a good future. Duals should always be a part of the ISWA season and hopefully built on as the years go by.
That brings up the next topic that has me baffled........How can you manually seed the top 4 teams from a previous year? What criteria, besides them placing in the top 4 should guarantee them separation the following year? If that's honestly the case, then the top 4 teams should return with the same lineup from bottom to top. I'll even throw in the same wrestlers at different weights. As long as the team is the same as the previous season, all will be good. However, there is no way for that to be possible. For one, your older wrestlers at 6th grade move on to middle school.....You will generally come across a nice little 40 lb brick wall to add to the mix.....family's move in, family's move out.....heck, its possible that a wrestler will hang up his headgear to live the dream of travel basketball (please forget that I even used that as an example). Nonetheless, I hope you get my point.
If this were individual, yes, there should be separation. BUT, this is a team event which should call for some different form of separation.
My thought is this.......Indiana clubs and the ISWA need to sit a round table and come up with a seeding or "separation" criteria that's either all or none. It can be based on your team rank using trackwrestling or another recordkeeping program. My belief is that last season is last season. If you want to be separated from another club, you need to earn that during the season. Since the ISWA sanctions elementary duals, results should be easily accessible. Not sure if there is more to it than what im thinking and if there is, please let me know your thoughts. Im 40 years old, but im not ashamed to learn new things.
Second, whichever the result is....setting brackets or pools should be a public meeting. I am unsure if the date and time was missed, but it was stated on the second page of the state dual flier that a time and date would be sent out. Again, if this notification ended up in my junk mail, my apologies and lets move on.
This is not intended to start bickering or a war, however, I've been that small team that was on the outside looking in and the changes mentioned above will GROW the number of clubs participating in the dual season. We've seen it first hand.
Feel free to comment as I would like to gather some thoughts from others. Again, this isn't meant to start bickering or bad feelings, its meant to make it better for the next guy. If any of you know me on and off the mat, you know that im not the type of person to start a fire.
Thanks for taking the time to read.
Coach Shelton
Franklin Central Wrestling Club