I wanted to throw an idea out and see what others thought.......
I have read most of the 'class wrestling' vs 'one class' discussions here over the years and I can see the pros and cons of both sides of the argument. (I also understand that we coach in the largest school in the state)
Right after I started CIA, I remember going to see a big 32 team tourney over winter break to see the finals of kids that trained with us. I remember looking over to mat 4 and seeing the wrestling for 7th and 8th and then my opinion on class wrestling changed. Seeing the level of wrestling for 8th place of a 32 team tourney means that there were hypothetically 24 guys worse than the guy getting 8th. At that moment, my opinion of adding class wrestling moved in favor of starting class wrestling (as long as it keeps our state tourney in Bankers Life...but that's a different story).
If smaller schools had a chance for success against other smaller schools, I can only image that they'd go back to school, pronounce themselves as Sectional champions and get some notoriety in the school and making it more attractive for others to participate and hopefully that would help 'snowball' into a more solid program over time.
I believe that the top 10 percent of Indiana wrestling is as good as it's ever been in our state's history, and the bottom 10% is still the bottom 10%. What can we do to make sure the 'middle class' of Indiana wrestling is also getting better? Class wrestling could be something that could help.
Then my thought went to JV teams wrestling in varsity tournaments. This year Carmel sent their JV to a varsity tourney for the first time. They finished 7th in a 16 team tourney and had 1 champ. We were happy for them to have some quality matches. But if the top 10% of Indiana's teams (I'm definitely saying we're top 10%) didn't send their JV teams to varsity tourneys, wouldn't that leave a place for other teams to have success?
....and if nobody sent their JV to varsity tourneys, wouldn't that mean that we could get better JV tourneys because they would be looking for tough JVs to compete against?
I guess my question is that if we all stopped sending JVs to varsity tourneys, wouldn't it open up places for Indiana's 'middle class' programs to have more success? I'm thinking if we all stopped sending JV's to varsity tourneys it would be a baby step towards class wrestling and it would make opportunities to have better true JV matches.