I thought it would be interesting to see how each regional has fared at the state's toughest semi-state, Merrillville, over the last 5 years.. here is the breakdown (for those of you unfamiliar with the geographic distribution, I will include those that were State Champs and Runners-Up from each Regional) *Note that the Calumet and LaPorte regionals combined is the area often referred to as "Da Region":
2010: Calumet- 11 State Qualifiers, 7 of those were Medalists
2009: Calumet- 12 State Qualifiers, 8 of those were Medalists
2008: Calumet- 14 State Qualifiers, 9 of those were Medalists
2007: Calumet- 14 State Qualifiers, 8 of those were Medalists
2006: Calumet- 14 State Qualifiers, 7 of those were Medalists
2006-2010 Calumet SQ: 65
2006-2010 Calumet Medalists: 39
2006-2010 Calumet Friday Night at State Winning Percentage: 60.0%
State Champs from Calumet from 2006-2010: 10
(Kyle Ayersman-Lake Central, Frankie Porras-Hobart 2x, Brennan Cosgrove-Hobart, Eric Galka-Hobart, Eric McGill-Munster 2x, Jamal Lawrence-Merrillville, Javier Salas-Merrillville, Dexter Larimore-Merrillville)
Runners-Up from Calumet from 2006-2010: 5
(James Travis-Merrillville, Frankie Porras-Hobart, Eric Galka-Hobart, Brennan Cosgrove-Hobart 2x)
2010: LaPorte- 14 State Qualifiers, 9 of those were Medalists
2009: LaPorte- 15 State Qualifiers, 13 of those were Medalists
2008: LaPorte- 15 State Qualifiers, 10 of those were Medalists
2007: LaPorte- 17 State Qualifiers, 12 of those were Medalists
2006: LaPorte- 14 State Qualifiers, 9 of those were Medalists
2006-2010 LaPorte SQ: 75
2006-2010 LaPorte Medalists: 53
2006-2010 LaPorte Friday Night at State Winning Percentage: 70.66%
State Champs from LaPorte from 2006-2010: 14
(Eric Roach-Crown Point, Nathan Cleveland-Lowell, Anthony Hawkins-Crown Point, Jason Tsirtsis-Crown Point 2x, Sean McMurray- Portage 3x, Marcus Shrewsbury-Crown Point, Tom Churchard- Valparaiso, Andrew Howe-Hanover Central 3x, Chad Biddle-Portage)
Runners-Up from LaPorte from 2006-2010: 10
(Paul Petrov-Hanover Central, Danny Bradley-Knox, Anthony Quiroz-Chesterton, Eric Roach-Crown Point, Marcus Shrewsbury-Crown Point, Tom Churchard-Valparaiso, Andy St. Germain-Chesterton, Phillip Oudhuis-New Prairie, Derek Traversa-John Glenn, Adam Walters-Portage)
2010: Logansport- 10 State Qualifiers, 3 of those were Medalists
2009: Logansport- 12 State Qualifiers, 4 of those were Medalists
2008: Logansport- 8 State Qualifiers, 2 of those were Medalists
2007: Logansport- 6 State Qualifiers, 1 of those were a Medalist
2006: Logansport- 8 State Qualifiers, 3 of those were Medalists
2006-2010 Logansport SQ: 44
2006-2010 Logansport Medalists: 13
2006-2010 Logansport Friday Night at State Winning Percentage: 29.55%
State Champs from Logansport from 2006-2010: 0
Runners-Up from Logansport from 2006-2010: 2
(Braden Atwood-Delphi, Travis Dale-McCutcheon)
2010: Rochester- 21 State Qualifiers, 11 of those were Medalists
2009: Rochester- 17 State Qualifiers, 10 of those were Medalists
2008: Rochester- 19 State Qualifiers, 14 of those were Medalists
2007: Rochester- 19 State Qualifiers, 13 of those were Medalists
2006: Rochester- 20 State Qualifiers, 13 of those were Medalists
2006-2010 Rochester SQ: 96
2006-2010 Rochester Medalists: 61
2006-2010 Rochester Friday Night at State Winning Percentage: 63.54%
State Champs from Rochester from 2006-2010: 10
(Steve Sandefer-Mishawaka 2x, Daniel Young-Culver Academies, Josh Harper-Mishawaka 3x, Ian Hinton-Mishawaka 2x, George Malone-South Bend Riley, Pat Day-Mishawaka)
Runners-Up from Rochester from 2006-2010: 4
(Paul Beck-Mishawaka, Christian Lentz-Mishawaka 2x, Cory Fornal-Rochester)
On average..
Rochester- 19.2 Qualifers per year, 12.2 Medalists per year, .8 Runners-Up per year, 2 State Champs per year
LaPorte- 15.0 Qualifiers per year, 10.6 Medalists per year, 2 Runners-Up per year, 2.8 State Champs per year
Calumet- 13.0 Qualifiers per year, 7.8 Medalists per year, 1 Runner-Up per year, 2 State Champs per year
Logansport- 8.8 Qualifiers per year, 2.6 Medalists per year, .4 Runners-Up per year, 0 State Champs per year
As is well documented, Logansport is the weakest, though they have been getting more qualifiers with the emergence of Delphi as a state power, however the State Champs, Runners-Up, and Medalists are pretty much all coming from Calumet, LaPorte, and Rochester.
YoungOne... it's hard to argue against the data! The Logansport Regional comes into the Merrillville Semi-State every single year and gets throttled by the other 3 regionals. Then, if they are lucky enough to sneak through to state, they've only got about a 30% chance of winning on Friday night at state, compared to the other regionals which have probabilities between 60 and 70%! You're gonna have a hard time convincing me that more Logansport Regional kids (where Seeger hails from) need to be ranked. Only a little over half of their regional champions even make it out of the semi-state, and of those 8 or 10, only 2 or 3 ever find themselves on the podium on Saturday night, and never on the top step.