Hey, Tipthescales, how do you undo a year that has already happened? Do you have a time machine? If he wasn't eligible, the punishment needs to take place. You have to take away the entire experience and that can't happen retroactively. Very unfortunate this was his senior year. From what I've read, he's a good kid and he'll land on his feet. Hopefully, he learned a really good lesson from all of this and maybe some of the other wrestling programs will also learn a lesson.
I agree with others who have said to change the rules, but follow them until they change. A lot of energy is wasted complaining/speculating about the creeper who took the videos. The real issue is that a 5 person review board said he wasn't eligible. I would guess they had information the family is not fessing up to in the article, but who knows for sure. As for his move, come on, he was unhappy because a teacher accused him of cheating! When I read the article, it seemed obvious that this was done because he wanted to be on the dominant local team. Unfortunately, there is the right way to make this happen and the wrong way. They chose the wrong way and got caught.