I don't really have a dog in this fight but I don't like this train of thought and for the record, I'm a Sam Riesen fan.
When you have a committee deciding things about other people's programs, then you have an obligation to be able to explain yourself and to do that exact thing when asked. Maybe not on the board, but the reasoning should be readily available. It's the same thing with the sectional realignment. There is a committee that does the leg work for the IHSAA and then the IHSAA decides. But, when decisions are being made about 300+ programs, then those people have a duty to explain things. In the last year, I have heard from over 15+ head coaches that Rochester is moving back to the ECC Semi-State. That's frustrating to me. Why would other programs know about my program before I do? Why is it still difficult to get a straight answer? It'd be nice to know so I can start working on changing our schedule. Anyway, now I'm just venting.
I'm not a big fan of "secrecy" and I feel like these are always two big decisions that are always kept a "secret". I have the same gripe with the IHSAA. Why does everything have to be a big secret. You make the decision, so stand by it and explain it when asked. Again, when you represent a larger group and you make decisions on what is and is not best for the people and programs in that group, then you have an obligation to explain your reasoning to that group.