I believe for the most most we would continue to see most of the same teams in, with maybe 2 new teams appearing each year. Even if we had a 2 or 3 class team state system (which I am in favor of) we would still see the same team make it most years. However, I believe winning team sectional, team regional, and previously team semi-state recognition does go far to further the sports appeal in those communities. And in many areas the teams that won team sectional and the previous version of team regional did change every few years.
To me team state is the only pure way to determine the best team in state. In many years the team that wins the Coaches Trophey is not even in the finals of team state. Its not a true team title if a few individuals are giving you the points needed. Its not a true team title when not everyone even made it to state to start on an even level points wise. I have heard many people from other states comment that they are jelious that Indiana offers a team state title. Even many NCAA fans wish a true dual national champion was declared instead of determaning it by a system where only certain schools have enough stud individuals to have a chance at it.
To me team dual meets do grow a fan base and get more community support for your program. With the lose of team state we may see less dual meets as coaches decide is more important to pick up one or two more tournaments to prepare for individual state. Remember because of points each tournament you pick up is 2 less duals you can participate in. Sure we will still have duals but some areas will put less emphasis on them since it back to being much more of an individual sport if in the end all we haveis individual state. I agree with Hinton that their is something unique and almost more important when you win a key team dual. Knowing the guys you bleed and sweat with every day came together for a big dual win has something special to it that just an individual win over that team doesn't give you.
To me the experiance of seeing team state is entirely different than individual state and just as exciting. And this is coming from someone who has not had a team participate in it.
To me team sucess is the best way to grow a team. You as an individual may just have average success, but if you can help your team accomplish something greater than in the individual you still feel like you had accomplished something special in your wrestling career.
To me we short changed the chances of a sustained team state success by not making it into a 2 or 3 class system. With that more middle and small size school would have sectional and regional sucess leading to more recognition in their area and thus more team growth. By growing the sport in that way we would have had a beter selling point to why team state was worth keeping. However, in its current form teams stateisn't leading to as much team growth since i most cases winning a sectional title is as far as most team can reaslisically get at this point. The oversight of not trying to make a class team state system I believe was the biggest reason we are having this conversation today. It would have been as simple as putting 3-5 big teams, 3-5 middle size teams, and 3-5 small teams in each sectional and then awarding a sectional title to each size school based on team points then moving along the team tournament from there while keeping the individual event in place. That would create several more team regional site, and more participants, leading to more people and communities coming to watch these events, as well.
We can't blaim the top 15 teams for this since they developed a solid program but as a result of their talent they have shut out most other teams from having a chance an created this apathy for team state.
I like team state, I want t okeep team state. But unfortunately we and the IHSAA never found a way to properly nurture team states into a sucessful sports builder and money maker. Because of this I to fear that team state doesn't have much time. If it does end I hope we do seriously go back to restructuring the individual series at the sectional and regional level again since we no loger have to consider team state in its design. Maybe that way we can find ways to increase attendence and clean up some of the current issues (like having to win several matches to get to regionals but only 1 win in regionals gets you to semi-state).