seems like you compared it to a criminal court case to begin with... not me.. all i did was refute the fact that before i point a finger at a kid I am going to have to be 100 percent sure he did something wrong. Seems to me like that is a hard thing to do. Last I heard, the Reinoehl family had the purchase of the new house pending the sale of the old house and that the IHSAA said it was ok at first, but now they are unhappy that such transactions have not taken place. With the housing markets the way they are at this point it seems highly likely that they would be having a hard time to sell their house, as I have known a couple people trying to sell in this market and they are not even getting people to come look at their house. So in my mind, it sounds like both stories are probable, and it sounds like the father's story carries alot of weight.
Most school disticts in Indiana require proof of residence in order to enroll. In order to show proof of residence, you have to show that you have purchased a home or rent in the district, not intend to purchase one.
Someone else mentioned him living with his grandmother earlier in this thread. If so, have his parents given up parental rights?