Here's an interesting thought;Take a March Madness-like approach
Put together a selection committee through IHSAA or IHSWA similar to team state selections. It could be former coaches, officials and others that are involved in the sport but that can unbiased.
Select the top 8 wrestlers in each weight class in each current Regional on the last weekend of the regular season. Selections would be made based upon records, strength of schedule, placements in conference tournaments, bad losses and signature wins, etc.
Top 4 placers would move on after the Regional to Semi State and then the ol