With much of my extra time these past few months (bits here and there) I was kicking around the idea of rotating the semi-states clockwise about a county so it is more like true quarters of the state in order to rebalance the schools coming from each semi-state.
I'm attaching what I cam up with here in case anyone cares to peruse.
Semistate redistribution Idea.docx
A couple caveats:
1) The purpose was to rebalance the semi-states and maybe rebalance some regionals.
2) Don't get caught up in who is "hosting", I just did that for ease of identification of sectionals
3) There's some big changes in this and I know people who get moved into a "harder" sectional, regional, or semi-state will think it's a dumb idea, but I do think it solves a balance issue and would lead to a better state finals overall.
4) I did this solo, so good chance there are some errors with teams either not mentioned or being repeated on accident, just let me know if you find them.
5) Obviously, I had to get creative with Regional Pairings to make them as even as possible. One comes out pretty weak overall, but the other 15 are pretty even overall given geographical constraints.
The final breakdown of Team state eligible teams in each semi-state if we redrew the lines would be as follows:
East Chicago:
4A-8
3A-14
2A-20
1A-26
Total: 68
Ft. Wayne:
4A-9
3A-13
2A-21
1A-23
Total: 66
New Castle:
4A-10
3A-17
2A-19
1A-20
Total: 66
Evansville:
4A-8
3A-16
2A-21
1A-22
Total: 67
This is MUCH more balanced than our current semi-states.
Let me know what you think!
Possible?
Dumb Idea?
Does it help solve a problem we currently have?
Are there better solutions with less upheaval to traditional sectional rivalries?
All items for discussion.